John Phelps went to get his 16-year-old stepdaughter, Alzada Pauline Young, from a neighbor’s house. She had been avoiding him for nearly a week, and he had had enough. When they got home, a confrontation ensued and Pauline ended up dead on the kitchen floor, killed by a hammer in a single blow. John concealed the murder from his wife and family by hiding her body in the cellar. The next day, when they were out at school and work, he made her disappear…

A delivery man making a routine business stop on Route 148, in Madison, Maine, made a terrible discovery: 55-year-old Raynald Levesque was lying dead on his living room floor. Maine State Police still keep his unsolved murder case open since his death in 1994. His daughter, Julia, reflects on his life and provides a complete portrait of her father and their long wait for justice.

Ayla Reynolds’ disappearance is the largest criminal investigation in the state of Maine. According to her father, Justin DiPietro, 20-month-old Ayla disappeared from her crib in Waterville on the night of December 16, 2011. This Maine cold case remains unsolved as of 2021, but more answers may be forthcoming as mother, Trista Reynolds brings a wrongful death suit against father.

Marc Karun arrested after 33 years for the murder of 11-year-old Kathleen Flynn in Norwalk, CT. DNA evidence and police work, spanning decades, proves his undoing.

In 1991 in Waterville, Maine, Lorna Labbe Brackett and Vincent White were both murdered in a fire that was deliberately set to silence them. To this day, their homicide is still unsolved.