Episodes

 
 
Kristen Seavey Kristen Seavey

The Horrifying Murder of Alzada Pauline Young

John Phelps went to get his 16-year-old stepdaughter, Alzada Pauline Young, from a neighbor’s house. She had been avoiding him for nearly a week, and he had had enough. When they got home, a confrontation ensued and Pauline ended up dead on the kitchen floor, killed by a hammer in a single blow. John concealed the murder from his wife and family by hiding her body in the cellar. The next day, when they were out at school and work, he made her disappear…

Read More
A week ago I got back from Dallas for the @truecrimepodcastfestival and I’m still feeling the high from meeting so many amazing people! It was the first time Murder, She Told has been to a convention, and this past month a lot of work was put i
Shawn O’Brien was the life of the party. Despite the trouble that he'd occasionally get into, he had the luck of the Irish, and would often emerge unscathed... until one hot summer night in 2006, when everything changed... Paramedics arrived t
Coming in on the final days of summer! 🍉 I always feel a bit bittersweet because I love summer, but I also really love fall! It’s been a weird summer, so I think I’m more ready for fall this year than I have been in the past. 🎃🍁 Ar
This is Ray’s Welding Shop in Madison, ME, one of Ray Levesque’s proudest accomplishments. It was his first endeavor into being an entrepreneur, bringing his skills as a welder home by starting his own business. He would later have a bo
On the evening of August 8th, 1980, 16-year-old Joyce McLain went out for a jog near her home in East Millinocket and never came home. A few days later, her body was recovered near a power line clearing close to the very soccer field she was set to p
So what does a 1983 missing persons case file look like? This is part of the case file for Reeves Johnson. There was no crime scene, and the original investigation was very small; after all, he was an adult, and there was only so much a local police